September 9, 2026, I sat down at my desk and was ready to get my homework done. I 9, 2026, I sat down at my desk and was ready to get my homework done. I opened my email to catch up on what I had missed while I was in classes. Everything was the usual: emails from the bookstore, chapel office, and Canvas updates that I barely pay attention to. But one from my Resident Director caught my eye. I opened it up and in bright red, bolded,. But one from my Resident Director caught my eye. I opened it up and in bright red, bolded, and underlined text it read, “If you’re tempted to skip this entire email, the summary is that there will be a fine given to every resident on the Hill if there is not a significant decrease of trash being left outside of the dumpsters over the next 2 weeks.” I was personally shocked, to say the least. We were exactly two weeks into the semester and there was already an email being sent to approximately 450 resident students at Gordon College that they would be potentially getting fined. I looked outside my window to see the dumpsters in question, and saw that trash bags. I looked outside my window to see the dumpsters in question, and saw that trash bags were starting to show at the top of the fence, which disgusted me. starting to show at the top of the fence, which disgusted me.
And that is when the talking started. Upon hearing this information, it quickly became a topic among the Hill residents whether or not they would be getting fined for something that most of them did not do. “I think it is unjust to everybody who puts effort into actually caring for creation to fine them for other people not caring,” an anonymous Nyland resident said. Another anonymous Nyland resident mentioned that they felt like this group punishment was akin to one team member making a mistake and the whole sports team getting punished.
Some residents have even thought of it to be a bluff and did not necessarily take it seriously. But with the fact that it might be a bluff in mind, residents are irritated that this could be used against them. “It’s a scare tactic that will probably not even get the perpetrators to stop because it’s so ridiculous. It is ineffective and anxiety-provoking,” an anonymous Fulton resident explained. Taking this into account, Gordon College is a place students come to learn and grow in their faith and community; they do not come here to get scared by trusted authority figures for something the majority of them did not do.
However, residents are agreeing that we are in fact college students and we need to be responsible with how we treat our campus and the resources given to us through the school. They just think that they could put this issue into more encouraging words rather than intimidation. “I understand the threat even though I think it isn’t something that they would go. “I understand the threat even though I think it isn’t something that they would go through with. And I don’t like that it is something that is threatening the entirety of the Hill when it could just be like, ‘Hey, you are caught doing this’ instead.” an anonymous Nyland resident said.
Many have experienced getting fined at least $25 for something in their dorm rooms that they did not cause; but being a part of a mass fine is something new for most students. One anonymous Nyland resident explains that they feel they are not in the wrong, but may get fined for someone else’s mistake. “I am a student with a reduced meal plan for health reasons and I pay around $50 for my normal groceries. So that’s about half of what I would spend on groceries for someone else throwing trash on the ground.” Some students are on a strict budget when it someone else throwing trash on the ground.” Some students are on a strict budget when it comes to outside spending (especially for those in Tavilla) and having a $25 fine for something that they did not directly do can be a financial strain.
That being said, students are here at Gordon to be a part of a secure and flourishing are here at Gordon to be a part of a secure and flourishing community rather than being on their toes and turning on one another a couple of weeks into the semester because of the actions of a small percentage of their fellow residents. While it was justified to send out an email reminding our student body to be mindful of how we ought to treat our campus, it does not seem appropriate to threaten college students with their own money if they were not a part of the problem. were not a part of the problem.
Leave a Reply